Sherrard Elementary was a weird architectural amalgamations of the very old and the very new. The original structure was built in 1925, and was fairly typical of the intermediate model of schooling. An addition built in 1972 onto the front of the building added a few classrooms and an auditorium to the front of the building.
Declining enrollment led to the closure of Sherrard at the end of the 2006 school year. Sherrard and the nearby Breitmeyer school were demolished in 2010.